Fake diamond fools even experts
Excerpts from Chicago Tribune
February 11, 2003
Edition: North Sport Final, Section: Tempo, Page: 2
Fake diamond fools even experts
Author: Sabine Morrow, Cox News Service.
It’s nearly as hard as a diamond, boasts more brilliance and fire, costs a fraction as much and — get this – it can and has fooled many jewelers into thinking it was the real McCoy.
Such a gem isn’t wishful thinking, although the original did come from a star.
Sue Schlotter, manager of Farsi Jewelers in Atlanta, has been selling the gem for about three years. “We do mostly special orders on moissanite. We combine them with diamonds. We also do replacements. I have a diamond earring that I lost, so I had the exact one made with moissanite and no one can tell it’s not a diamond,” she says.
The diamond Schlotter replaced was just under a carat. A diamond replacement would have cost about $2,000, but she spent $500 on a moissanite instead.
Diamonds’ cachet - But why purchase a man-made gem when part of a diamond’s cachet is that it’s such a rare jewel? That’s a total myth.
Consider that in 2001 the United States imported more than 17 million carats of natural-cut and uncut diamonds worth more than $10.5 billion, according to the U.S. Geological Survey. “To date, less than 1 million carats of moissanite have been produced for sale to the public,” Thomas says.
Much of moissanite’s appeal is that its properties so closely approximate those of diamonds. It’s the hardest known man-made substance and hits only
slightly below that of diamond on the Mohs scale, which tests and rates the hardness of minerals on a 10-point scale. A diamond tests 10 and moissanite comes in at 9.25.
While no other substance matches the thermal conductivity of a diamond, moissanite is close enough to make electronic diamond testers beep positive. And that makes some merchants and customers more than a bit nervous.
But not Joe Ellis, owner of Cherokee Pawn in Alpharetta, Ga., who quickly spotted the moissanite when handed a diamond, cubic zirconia and the
moissanite without being told what they were.“It almost looks too good,” he said as he peered at the nearly 1-carat moissanite through his jeweler’s loupe. “My gut says it isn’t real.”
Beyond instinct - Still, Ellis didn’t rely solely on his experienced “gut.” He brought out the diamond tester. It beeped, indicating that the stone was a diamond. “This is a moissanite,” he insisted, an assertion he confirmed with another piece of equipment specifically designed to identify moissanite. It beeped; the stone indeed was no diamond. “That’s the problem with it,” Ellis said. “It’ll fool a diamond tester, and that’s how a customer can get the shaft.”
It’s another matter to talk to customers about how they like their moissanite jewelry. Try to find someone who will confirm having bought any.
“It’s like plastic surgery,” says Joan Carver, an associate with Landau. “Everybody loves it, but nobody will admit to having it done.”